You were rear-ended at a stoplight. The other driver was clearly at fault, and the police report confirms it. So why is your insurance company still asking about it two years later?
Not at fault accidents stay on your insurance record for 3-5 years in most states, and they can affect your premiums even when you did nothing wrong. This reality surprises many drivers who assume fault determination protects them from rate increases.
Your driving record (maintained by the DMV) and your insurance claims history (tracked by databases like CLUE) operate independently. Both retain accident information, but for different time periods and purposes. Insurers access both when calculating your premiums.
Whether you're shopping for new coverage after an accident or trying to understand a recent rate increase, knowing how long this information follows you—and which states offer protections—helps you make smarter insurance decisions.
How Long Not at Fault Accidents Stay on Your Record
The answer depends on which record you're asking about. Multiple databases track your accident history, each with different retention periods.
State DMV Records
Most state DMVs maintain accident records for 3-5 years. Here's how specific states handle retention:
- California: 3 years from the accident date
- North Carolina: 3 years
- New York: 3 years
- Michigan: 3 years
- Texas: 5 years
- Florida: 3-5 years depending on accident type
CLUE Reports
The Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (CLUE), maintained by LexisNexis Risk Solutions, tracks all insurance claims you file—regardless of fault—for up to 7 years. This database shows insurers your complete claims history when you apply for new coverage or renewals.
Many drivers don't realize CLUE reports exist. You can request a free copy annually to verify accuracy.
Insurance Company Internal Records
Insurers maintain their own databases beyond CLUE. These records may follow you indefinitely within that company's system, though most only use the past 3-5 years for rating purposes.
The Rating Period vs. The Record Period
Insurance companies typically look back 3-5 years when calculating premiums. This "rating period" determines how long an accident actively affects your rates. The accident may remain on various records longer, but its impact on premiums diminishes or disappears after the rating period ends.
Your state and insurer determine the exact lookback period. Some insurers use 3 years; others extend to 5. When shopping for coverage after an accident, ask each company about their specific rating period.
How Not at Fault Accidents Affect Your Insurance Rates
Here's the uncomfortable truth: not at fault accidents can increase your premiums in most states. The impact typically ranges from 0-12%, translating to $0-$300 per year in additional costs.
Why Insurers Raise Rates for Not at Fault Accidents
Insurance companies use statistical models to predict future claims. Some data suggests drivers who have been in accidents—regardless of fault—file more claims than drivers with clean records. Insurers view any claim as a risk indicator.
The type of claim matters too. Comprehensive claims (theft, weather damage, vandalism) typically have minimal impact, averaging $50-$200 in annual increases. Collision claims, even when you're not at fault, tend to carry more weight in rating calculations.
States That Prohibit Not at Fault Surcharges
Two states explicitly protect drivers from rate increases after not at fault accidents:
California: Proposition 103 prohibits insurers from raising rates based solely on not at fault accidents. The California Department of Insurance enforces this consumer protection.
Oklahoma: State regulation 365:15-3-44 prohibits insurers from surcharging for not at fault accidents.
If you live in these states, your not at fault accident shouldn't directly increase your premiums. However, the claim still appears on your CLUE report, which other insurers can see if you switch carriers.
States With Limited Protections
Several states have regulations that limit rate increases or require insurers to justify them:
- North Carolina: A rate filing system limits discretionary increases
- Michigan: The no-fault system means most claims don't determine fault for rating purposes
- New York: Most drivers see minimal to no rate impact from not at fault accidents
What About Police Reports and Citations?
A common misconception: if the other driver was cited, your rates definitely won't increase. Police reports and fault determinations don't always prevent rate increases. Insurers use their own underwriting criteria, which may differ from legal fault determinations.
Not at Fault vs. At Fault Accidents: Impact Comparison
| Factor | Not at Fault Accident | At Fault Accident |
|---|---|---|
| Time on driving record | 3-5 years (varies by state) | 3-5 years (varies by state) |
| Time on CLUE report | Up to 7 years | Up to 7 years |
| Average premium increase | 0-12% ($0-$300/year) | 20-50% ($400-$1,500/year) |
| Protected states | California, Oklahoma | None (all states allow increases) |
| Impact on accident forgiveness | Usually doesn't trigger; may still use it | Triggers forgiveness if available |
| Effect when switching insurers | New insurer sees claim on CLUE | New insurer sees claim on CLUE |
| Typical rating weight | Low to moderate | High |
The key difference: at fault accidents almost always increase premiums significantly, while not at fault accidents may have zero impact depending on your state and insurer.
What You Can Do to Minimize the Impact
Before Filing a Claim
Consider whether filing makes financial sense. For minor damage, paying out of pocket might cost less than potential premium increases over 3-5 years. Calculate the repair cost against possible rate increases of $0-$300 annually.
If the other driver's insurance pays your claim directly, the accident may still appear on your CLUE report, but your insurer won't have a claim on their internal records.
Shop Around After an Accident
Insurers weigh not at fault accidents differently. Some apply no surcharge; others factor claims into their risk models. Getting quotes from multiple companies reveals who penalizes you least.
When comparing rates, ask specifically: "How do you rate drivers with a not at fault accident in the past 3 years?" Direct questions get clearer answers.
Request Your Reports
Order your CLUE report annually from LexisNexis to verify accuracy. Errors happen—incorrect fault determinations, accidents listed that weren't yours, or claims reported multiple times. Dispute inaccuracies immediately.
Consider Accident Forgiveness
Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent rate increases after your first accident. Check if your policy includes this feature, and whether a not at fault accident triggers it or preserves it for future use.
Wait It Out
If you've recently had a not at fault accident and your rates increased, mark your calendar for 3 years out. Request a re-quote at that point—the accident should no longer factor into your premium calculation with most insurers.
Compare Insurance Rates After an Accident
Insurance companies rate not at fault accidents differently. Some apply no surcharge; others increase premiums by 10% or more for the same claim. The only way to find the best rate after an accident is to compare multiple quotes.
Getting quotes from several insurers takes time, but drivers who compare save an average of $500+ annually. This matters even more when an accident is affecting your rates.
Enter your information once and see how different insurers price your specific situation—including that not at fault accident on your record.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a not at fault accident raise my insurance rates?
In most states, yes—insurers can raise rates after any accident, regardless of fault. Typical increases range from 0-12%. California and Oklahoma prohibit this practice. Your specific impact depends on your state, insurer, and claims history.
Does a not at fault accident show up on my driving record?
Yes. State DMVs record accidents regardless of fault. This information remains on your driving record for 3-5 years in most states. The accident also appears on your CLUE report for up to 7 years.
Can I remove a not at fault accident from my record?
No, you cannot remove accurate accident information. You can dispute errors on your CLUE report or DMV record if the information is incorrect. Accurate records remain until the standard retention period expires.
Should I file a claim for a not at fault accident?
Filing a claim creates a record that follows you for years. For minor damage, calculate whether repair costs exceed potential premium increases over 3-5 years. For significant damage or injuries, filing usually makes sense regardless of potential rate impact.
Do all insurance companies check CLUE reports?
Most major insurers access CLUE reports when you apply for coverage or at renewal. This means switching companies doesn't hide your claims history—the new insurer will see your previous claims regardless of which company paid them.
See What You Should Be Paying
Get a free 2026 estimate based on your driver profile, vehicle, and state.
Use the Free Calculator →